The Bagpipe Pages
From Icon to Identity – Abstract
(Download pdf-file – Click here.)

From Icon to Identity. Scottish Piping & Drumming in Scandinavia

ISBN 91 85974 71-4, ISSN 1650-9285

Skrifter från Institutionen för musikvetenskap, Göteborgs universitet nr. 75, 2003

Doctoral dissertation in English, 400 pages.

Mats d Hermansson, Göteborg University, Department of Musicology & Film Studies

Key words:    bagpipe, drum, pipe band, icon, identity, Scandinavia, Scotland, Highland, function of music, imaginary world, impact of music, insider, outsider, learning music.

In the 1960s, a few individuals in Scandinavia got so interested in Scottish Highland piping and pipe band drumming that they started to play themselves, although there was no existing tradition for this music in Scandinavia, and they formed a small community of dedicated pipers and drummers.

The major objectives of this thesis is to analyse the background to why and processes through which the marginal culture of Scottish piping and drumming spread to and developed in Scandinavia as well as to interrogate what use and function this genre of music may have in Scandinavia.

Highland piping emerged as part of the clan chiefs’ power structure in the Gaelic clan society of the Scottish Highlands in the sixteenth century. Later, the Great Highland Bagpipe was adopted by the British army where it retained its function of representing political power, further strengthened by the formation of bands of pipers and drummers in the nineteenth century. The bagpipe also became a strong romantic icon of Scotland, an image spread over the world by the British army and later by mass media, making the Great Highland Bagpipe the bagpipe.

Many of the Scandinavian pioneers acquired their interest at the encounter of the impressive appearance of a pipe band. In the thesis, the mechanisms behind the formation of an interest as a fantasy and its realisation are discussed against a framework of psychoanalytical concepts related to identity and personal identity choices facilitated and required by modern Western society.

The Scandinavian enthusiasts met with a very strong tradition of Scottish pipers and drummers who were more than willing to share their knowledge and culture. By means of books, recordings and a few lessons, a number of Scandinavians managed to learn and develop their playing, gradually copying the Scottish tradition.

The initial interest of the pioneers was directed both towards the music and the iconic extramusical aspects of the genre, but today the music and the competitive aspects of the genre are at the centre of interest for most players. The general audience in Scandinavia still sees the genre as an icon of Scotland or as something exotic.

The pioneers sought an identity in the icon of an exotic genre of music but found an identity as members of a small world-wide community of like minded musicians.

© Mats d Hermansson 2008
Joomla Templates By Joomladesigns
20 queries executed
SELECT template, client_id, menuid FROM mos_templates_menu WHERE (client_id=0 or client_id=1) AND (menuid=0 OR menuid=63) ORDER BY client_id, menuid
2 DELETE FROM mos_session WHERE (time<1590686126 AND guest>=0) OR (time<1590683426 AND guest<0)
3 SELECT * FROM mos_session WHERE session_id='a931a9c09f8c38f062f665d8660f1a13'
4 SELECT session_id FROM mos_session WHERE session_id=MD5('7472dc13298b6c240d6bc1a9c94ebd80')
5 INSERT INTO mos_session ( `session_id`,`time`,`userid`,`username`,`gid`,`guest` ) VALUES ( '12ada05f853fedcec756814d90debd49','1590687026','0','','0','1' )
6 SELECT count(*), type FROM mos_stats_agents WHERE (agent='Unknown' AND type=0) OR (agent='Unknown' AND type=1) OR (agent='com' AND type=2) GROUP BY type
7 UPDATE mos_stats_agents SET hits=(hits+1) WHERE agent='Unknown' AND type=0
8 UPDATE mos_stats_agents SET hits=(hits+1) WHERE agent='Unknown' AND type=1
9 UPDATE mos_stats_agents SET hits=(hits+1) WHERE agent='com' AND type=2
10 SELECT folder, element, published, params, CONCAT_WS('/',folder,element) AS lookup FROM mos_mambots WHERE published >= 1 AND access <= 0 ORDER BY ordering
11 SELECT * FROM mos_menu ORDER BY name
12 SELECT group_id FROM mos_core_acl_aro_groups WHERE name='Registered'
13 SELECT group_id FROM mos_core_acl_aro_groups WHERE name='Author'
14 SELECT a.*, ROUND(v.rating_sum/v.rating_count) AS rating, v.rating_count, AS author, u.usertype, AS category, AS section, AS groups FROM mos_content AS a LEFT JOIN mos_categories AS cc ON = a.catid LEFT JOIN mos_sections AS s ON = cc.section AND s.scope='content' LEFT JOIN mos_users AS u ON = a.created_by LEFT JOIN mos_content_rating AS v ON = v.content_id LEFT JOIN mos_groups AS g ON a.access = WHERE'41' AND (a.state = '1' OR a.state = '-1') AND (publish_up = '0000-00-00 00:00:00' OR publish_up <= '2020-05-28 18:30:26') AND (publish_down = '0000-00-00 00:00:00' OR publish_down >= '2020-05-28 18:30:26') AND a.access <= 0
15 UPDATE mos_content SET hits=(hits+1) WHERE id='41'
16 SELECT hits FROM mos_core_log_items WHERE time_stamp='2020-05-28' AND item_table='#__content' AND item_id='41'
17 UPDATE mos_core_log_items SET hits=(hits+1) WHERE time_stamp='2020-05-28' AND item_table='#__content' AND item_id='41'
18 SELECT id, title, module, position, content, showtitle, params, published, m.access, m.groups FROM mos_modules AS m, mos_modules_menu AS mm WHERE m.access <= '0' AND m.client_id='0' AND AND (mm.menuid = '63' OR mm.menuid = '0') ORDER BY ordering
19 SELECT a.params, a.option FROM mos_components AS a WHERE = 'Syndicate'
20 SELECT a.params, a.option FROM mos_components AS a WHERE = 'Syndicate'